Name	Brewer	WifeRating	HusbandRating	WifeComments	HusbandComments	Average	Year
Pumpkinhead	Shipyard	8	6	Pumpkiny	"Good, not great"	7	2011
Harvest Moon	Blue Moon	2	3	Doesn't even taste like pumpkin beer	Too wheaty	2.5	2011
Harvest Time	Big Boss	6	7.5	"Good initial taste, weird aftertaste"	"Good taste, nice spice, but not bold enough"	6.75	2011
Pumking	Southern Tier	9	9	caramelly and delicious.  sweet.  almost creamy.	"strong vanilla nose, vanilla and spice initial taste"	9	2011
Postroad	Brooklyn Brewery	8	8	good fall spice taste	"Similar to 'harvest time', but slightly bolder tones of pumpkin"	8	2011
La Parcela - No 1 Pumpkin Ale	Jolly Pumpkin Artisan Ales	3	2	sour.	"practically a cider, pumpkin taste not very noticable"	2.5	2011
Pumkin Ale	Carolina Beer Company	10	9	DELICIOUS!  takes like pumpkin pie!  maybe even pumpkin pie with whipped cream on top.	solid pumpkin flavor	9.5	2011
Ichabod Ale	New Holland	7	6	no comment	no comment	6.5	2011
Pumpkin Ale	Thirsty Dog	9	8	"pumpkiny, fall spice - good"	smoove	8.5	2011
Pumpkin Ale	KBC	8	5	"tastes sort of like cream soda, but with a definite pumpkin flavor "	kind of soda poppy	6.5	2013
Cottonwood Pumpkin	Foothills	6	4	"lots of spice taste... good, but taste more of the spices than the pumpkin"	too many spices	5	2013
Jack-O Shandy	Traveler	8	7.5	"good pumpkin flavor.  delicious on draft, but not quite as good from the bottle.  Good pumpkin, but a bit of sprite like taste."	Good pumpkin taste without pumpkin spice.	7.75	2014
Pumpkin Ale	Saranac	6	5	"okay beer, but not much pumpkin flavor"	kind of bland	5.5	2014
Johnny Rails Pumpkin Ale	Erie Brewing Company	3	8	tastes more like cream soda than pumpkin.	good.  pretty refreshing.  drinkable.	5.5	2016
Pumpkick	New Belgium	9	2	"Unique and delicious!  Like pumpkin bread with cranberries!  Crisp cranberry beginning, smooth pumpkiny finish.  Yum!"	Weird. Tastes like grapefruit. Could not see myself drinking a whole one.	5.5	2016
Harvest Pumpkin Ale	Blue Moon	7	4	"Nothing special, but a solid pumpkin beer"	"Nice pumpkiny taste up front, but a very bitter finish - shoe polishy finish."	5.5	2016
Master of Pumpkins	Troegg	5	10	Lots of spice - more spice than pumpkin.  Too alchoholy.	Real authentic pumpkin taste	7.5	2019
Trick or Treat: Chocolate Pumpkin Porter	Evil Genius Beer Company	8	10	"Rich, creamy, delicious!  "	I like chocolate	9	2019